“SugarDaddyForMe Review” — Expert Opinions (And 5 Other Choices)

Online Dating

“SugarDaddyForMe Review” — Expert Opinions (And 5 Other Choices)

Hayley Matthews Hayley Matthews • 6/02/17

Some people tend to have a certain image in their head when they think about the sugar daddy and sugar baby relationship. For example, there’s a “Sex and the City” episode in which Samantha dates a significantly older man, and she loves being spoiled with expensive jewelry and fancy dinners. That is, until it’s time to get down to the nitty-gritty. She literally runs out of the room screaming after seeing his ass, which is, you guessed it, very wrinkly.

But the things we see on TV or in movies, and the things we read online, aren’t exactly accurate. A lot of the time, they’re meant to be humorous or are based on stereotypes. Millions of people are actually genuinely interested in this kind of arrangement, and the best way for them to find it is through dating websites like SugarDaddyForMe.com. Our experts have reviewed all the ins and outs of the site below so you’re as informed as possible when you decide if it’s right for you.

SugarDaddyForMe Review | 5 Other Choices

SugarDaddyForMe: 4 Million Users But Lots of Inactive Profiles

With more than 4 million members and 2,000 people signing up every day, SugarDaddyForMe.com, which was founded in 2004, says it’s the “world’s largest sugar daddy dating site.” Also, in regards to popularity, SugarDaddyForMe was featured on MTV’s True Life in the episode called “I’m a Sugar Baby” (for whatever that’s worth).

According to the site, male members are affluent, generous, and caring and are looking for serious relationships with someone who they can mentor and pamper — while the female members are young and attractive and desire a long-term commitment with someone who can support them and provide a luxurious lifestyle.

In terms of registration, you have a couple of affordable options: a free three-day trial or a five-day full-access pass for 99 cents. Either way, all you have to do is input your username, password, email address, gender, and birth date (you must be at least 18 years old). You can upload as many photos as you want, and your profile should be approved in 10 minutes or less, as the site claims. Then you can start looking for matches.

Screenshot of the SugarDaddyForMe Browse page

SugarDaddyForMe has tons of options for finding matches, including Quick Search, Easy Search, and Advanced Search.

The Quick Search requires you to specify if you’re a sugar daddy seeking a sugar baby or vice versa and allows you to sort by age, location, and profiles with photos. The Easy Search and Advanced Search include extra filters like height, body type, race, marital status, who’s online now, and who logged in most recently.

If you don’t want to search on your own, you’ll see dozens of compatible profiles on the Browse page, which has tabs at the top labeled Most Viewed, Hot Locals, New Members, and New Photos. On the left side are also featured members who might be a good fit for you.

In addition to the search functionality, SugarDaddyForMe has over a dozen other features, including:

  • Receive email notifications about matches
  • Send virtual kisses and likes
  • Add members to your Favorites list
  • Know when someone sent you a kiss or like
  • Receive an email when new members in your area sign up
  • Writes notes on member profiles to remember what you like about them
  • Upload private or Members-Only photos only paying members can see
  • Hide your profile whenever you want
  • Make your profile password protected
  • Suspend your profile whenever you want
  • Audio and video instant messaging
  • Use PowerMatch to send mass emails to members who meet your criteria
  • See which messages have been read, saved, or deleted
  • Have your profile shown at the top of search results
  • Have your profile highlighted so people know you’re a premium member

You can access all of these features with the trials we mentioned above but only for a certain time. If you decide the site is for you, upgrade to a Silver or Gold membership. The Silver One Month costs $34.90, the Gold One Month costs $39.90, the Silver + Total Access One Month costs $49.85, and the Gold + Total Access One Month costs $49.85.

Other components include a weekly dating schedule, where you can see who’s nearby and available for a date, and exclusive surveys. For example, SugarDaddyForMe’s latest survey was about single moms who were looking for sugar daddies.

Over 50% said they joined the site because they need financial help, 18% because they’re attracted to older men, 7% because they’re attracted to rich men, 6% because they want to travel the world with a sugar daddy, and 5% because they specifically want assistance paying for an apartment, a new car, or college tuition. Make of that what you will.

A very important thing worth noting is that during our research on SugarDaddyForMe, we found a lot of comments about people coming across tons of inactive or fake profiles and having trouble canceling their memberships. When you sign up, keep an eye out for members asking for money and auto renewals, and make sure you read the fine print.

Screenshot of a SugarDaddyForMe profile

While SugarDaddyForMe has a lot of features, we’ve seen a lot of complaints about inactive and fake profiles as well as an unresponsive customer support team.

Sarah P. shared her story on SiteJabber: “I’ve been scammed twice. These so-called ‘sugar daddies’ are not real sugar daddies. This website is absolutely horrible. I’ve never had a good experience from the site. There are a lot of fake people on there and scammers from different countries. Stay away from this site. You will get hurt.”

Really the only good reviews we could find of SugarDaddyForMe were on the site itself. JT, a 19-year-old sugar baby from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, said, “My experience on SugarDaddyForMe has been the best. I met some of the world’s best sugar daddies on here… they are truly gentlemen, and I would never have met them if it wasn’t for the site…. this dad dating website has given me the opportunity to pay off my bills and travel the world.”

If you have any problems or want to report a suspicious member, the site does have customer support that can be reached 24/7 through the contact form and Monday through Saturday via (800) 975-5616. However, we’ve also seen complaints that the customer support team doesn’t respond very quickly or at all.

5 Other Choices Our Experts Recommend

Clearly, SugarDaddyForMe has a few significant kinks it needs to work out, but don’t worry. This isn’t the only dating site out there for sugar daddies and sugar babies. We have five other sites we really like. While none of these are strictly for this niche audience, they do have large user bases and helpful search capabilities that let you get super specific about your needs.

★★★★★
4.9/5.0

Relationships: Casual Dates, Deep Relationships

Match System: Search by age, profile, zip, more

Our Experts Say: “Match.com has led to more dates, marriages and relationships than any other site. Its impressive user base and success rate make it our top review...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

Match.com is the most well-known dating site on the web. It’s been around since 1995 and, therefore, is responsible for the most romantic connections. More than 30 million people have signed up for Match.com, and more than 13.5 million singles visit the site every month. More than likely, you’ll have no problem finding that special someone. The site also has a variety of ways to sort its members, including by age, income, and location.

★★★★
4.4/5.0

Relationships: Casual Dates, Deep Relationships

Match System: Search by age, profile, zip, more

Our Experts Say: “OurTime is quickly gaining popularity amongst older singles, featuring an extensive profile search and simple interface. Exclusively for ages 50+...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

While OurTime says it’s strictly for singles over 50, anyone over 18 is allowed to join. If you’re a woman in her 20s or 30s and are attracted to mature, well-off men, OurTime has the targeted user base you’re looking for. Bonus: Since OurTime is part of the People Media family, when you sign up, you’re automatically signed up for SeniorPeopleMeet as well. A two for one!

★★★★
4.0/5.0

Relationships: Casual Dates, Deep Relationships

Match System: Search by age, profile, zip, more

Our Experts Say: “BlackPeopleMeet.com is the largest online dating site for black and biracial daters of all backgrounds, and is used by 1.4 million daters each month...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

You don’t necessarily have to be black or biracial to join BlackPeopleMeet, because people of all ethnicities are welcome, but a majority of the members are. You can get very detailed in your profile about your wants (e.g., lifestyle habits), and you can post video and audio messages so people can get to know you on a different level. Look for matches by yourself by using BlackPeopleMeet’s search tools, or just sit back and let them pick out the compatible people for you.

★★★★
3.6/5.0

Relationships: Casual Dates, Deep Relationships

Match System: Free to browse. Easy search options

Our Experts Say: “SeniorPeopleMeet.com is the most popular dating site exclusively for those 55 and older. Safe and easy to use, with a free trial to view profiles...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

We mentioned SeniorPeopleMeet earlier, and it’s pretty much just like its sister site, OurTime. Because the layout is straightforward, it only takes a couple of minutes to get started, and you don’t have to pay anything to do so. However, SeniorPeopleMeet focuses on helping singles aged 55 or older, while OurTime tends to have a wider range.

★★★★
3.5/5.0

Relationships: Hookups, Chats

Match System: Search by interest, zip code, photos, more

Our Experts Say: “BeNaughty is a popular "hookup" site that drops all the pretenses of dating and just gets down to the nitty-gritty of hooking up. The best part: browse profiles in any town for free...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

BeNaughty is the only site on our list that is most definitely not for relationships, but we wanted to include it in case a hookup is what you’re interested in. The users also tend to be younger, which could actually work out in your favor. If you’re an older man, you’ll have a significant number of lovely ladies to choose from. If you’re a younger woman interested in mature men, you won’t have to look very far.

Now It’s Time for You to Weigh the Pros and Cons of SugarDaddyForMe

SugarDaddyForMe.com does have certain things going for it, but the site also has some things going against it, causing people to have a negative opinion. As with anything in life, take the time to consider SugarDaddyForMe’s strengths and weaknesses for yourself. If you come to the conclusion that it’s not the dating site for you, we’ve got some really good backups.