Three Day Rule Matchmakers Insights On Compatibility

Women's Dating

Three Day Rule™ Matchmakers Use Unique Insights on Compatibility to Help Clients Find Love

Lauren Keys

Written by: Lauren Keys

Lauren Keys

Lauren Keys is a Contributing Editor for with over 9 years of writing experience with publications such as The New York Times, Gainesville Magazine and numerous other media outlets. Lauren focuses on telling the human side of the story when it comes to discussing all things dating. Her varied interests — from sci-fi to fitness to the Internet — keep her writing fresh and fun while informing readers of the latest trends.

Edited by: Lillian Castro

Lillian Castro

Lillian Guevara-Castro brings more than 30 years of journalism experience to ensure DatingAdvice articles have been edited for overall clarity, accuracy, and reader engagement. She has worked at The Atlanta Journal and Constitution, The Gwinnett Daily News, and The Gainesville Sun covering lifestyle topics.

Discuss This! Discuss This!
Advertiser Disclosure

The Short Version: When you can’t seem to find the right person after years on the dating scene, you might consider a matchmaking service to help deliver exactly what you’ve been looking for. But what if what you’ve been looking for isn’t right for you? The matchmakers at Three Day Rule function almost as therapists when they interview clients to get to the root of what they need in a significant other — even going as far as to ask why they think they’re still single and analyzing their exes using facial recognition to decode their type. Most of what they do is get clients to move past superficial requirements like perfect teeth or a certain height and focus instead on what actually plays into compatibility, like similar long-term goals and outlook on life. After a few months of iterations based on feedback from first dates, Three Day Rule finds that successful matches end up in long-lasting relationships and even marriage.

In high school, my friend Megan’s longest relationship was maybe a few months, which was pretty typical among our friends and for our age. None of us were all that picky about who we dated (as long as they were cool), and whenever we found ourselves in a relationship, we were focused on enjoying it to the fullest and breaking things off if it wasn’t making us happy. When I think about it now, I realize we just wanted to have fun and to laugh and to have someone find us interesting enough to talk to for hours at a time.

Somehow, 10 years and several relationships later, we’re all approaching 30, and Megan now has many prerequisites for a potential mate as well as a list of what drives her crazy. Rather than helping her find Mr. Right, her list ends up eliminating potential matches based on aspects that don’t play as big a role in actual compatibility.

From little things like chewing on pens or having a crooked nose to bigger turn-offs like career choice or a messaging misstep, people are going to naturally be more picky when considering spending more than a few months with someone. But do they really have to be?

Photo of Talia Goldstein, Founder of Three Day Rule

Talia Goldstein was matching co-workers from her cubicle before creating Three Day Rule.

When Talia Goldstein spoke to DatingAdvice recently, she asked us an important question she often pulls out on clients: “When you’re with your partner 70 years from now, did it ever really matter that he had perfect teeth or broad shoulders?”

As the Founder of the matchmaking service Three Day Rule, Talia said one of the biggest hurdles her company faces is helping clients see past the laundry list of little things they’re looking for in a mate. Her matchmakers instead look at three to four intangible attributes, such as outlook on life and shared sense of humor, to find clients the right fit.

Three Day Rule, or TDR, takes its name from the old (bad) advice of how long to wait before contacting your date. It’s the stereotype that things have to be perfect in dating that TDR hopes to shatter. The service works to find matches based on true compatibility, like alignment of long-term goals, and not superficial parameters, like “perfect hair.”

Types Play a Role in TDR Matchmaking

“When I was single, my type was what I call a stable indie rocker,” Talia said. Basically, a man who would go to shows with her and thoroughly enjoy the music while being successful in real life (which means definitely being able to pay his bills). “I ended up finding this attorney who was going to the same shows I was going to all the time.” Definitely, her “type,” she married him, and they now have two children together.

Photo of the Three Day Rule Logo

The thing about types is you have to understand when it works and when it doesn’t. TDR clients often think they want one type, but end up falling in love with a match with attributes outside of their ideal list. For example, one of Talia’s favorite success stories is that of a preppy woman who, donning pearls, asked to be set up with a corporate finance kind of guy, but Talia matched her with a rocker covered in tattoos and sporting long hair because they shared so many other aspects of personality. Talia says the two are now married with a baby on the way. (Success indeed!)

Part of what makes TDR unique, Talia explained, is the time it puts into data mining for its clients. The technologically advanced database her matchmakers work from includes details about past dates and even facial recognition. TDR interviews both the client and the match after a first date to learn what went right as well as what might have gone wrong.

“The typical dating websites don’t even know if the date happened,” Talia said. “And they certainly don’t know what happened after.”

Facial recognition helps TDR find matches based on what visual “type” clients seem to gravitate toward. Talia explained that often clients describe the perfect man, but when TDR analyzes the client’s exes, they don’t fit that ideal description and instead share a similar type of facial structure. With its propriety facial recognition technology, TDR can make matches clients are intrinsically drawn to physically beyond the larger, more relevant factors for compatibility.

A Thorough Process Helps Find Clients Better Dates

Overall more women use TDR, on average, and some cities, like San Francisco, have a more even gender split. Client ages vary, too, but Talia said the majority are in their 30s and turn to TDR because their busy work schedule keeps them from devoting much time to dating.

There are two lengths of contracts for TDR clients, three and six months. You can also be added to the TDR database for free, but you will only be considered a match for contract clients (which means you won’t receive any matchmaking for yourself). You can even transfer your dating profile into their database from partnered sites like Match and OKCupid.

Screenshot of how Three Day Rule works

Matchmakers at TDR make each date better than the last with post-date follow-up interviews.

Clients are first interviewed by a matchmaker on everything from the relationship they have with their parents to their aspirations and temperament. Clients can also submit images of exes for facial profiling to aid in the matching process. TDR matchmakers then spend time culling prospective singles from the shared company database and personally interview those who make the cut before suggesting a date for the client.

“A lot of our success stories end up with one of their last matches,” Talia explained of the thorough service contract clients receive. Her matchmakers are constantly iterating to find the next match throughout the contract based on post-date feedback. “I think the feedback is the best part of the entire service.”

If dates seem to go awry too often, TDR will actually go to events or bars as a wingman with clients to help coach them.

Pictures from Three Day Rule events

TDR hosts events for singles to meet each other and for matchmakers to mingle with prospects.

In addition to the digital profiles in the database, matchmakers find prospective singles for their clients by hosting events in the seven cities TDR supports — Los Angeles, New York, Chicago, Washington, D.C., Boston, San Francisco, and now Philadelphia. Local singles and TDR clients get the chance to mingle at events like a 50-person wine tasting and a 1,000-strong themed party.

More Matchmakers, More Cities, More Chances for Love

Remembering back to high school — before commitment was ‘til death, before there was that one horrible date with an “actor,” before we closed ourselves to a wide range of people to consider dating — we just wanted someone who we could spend an entire day with and want to do it all again tomorrow.

By analyzing dating history and narrowing down what is truly needed for happiness in a relationship, TDR matchmakers help clients find love they might have previously passed up.

Talia wants to make sure more people have access to TDR, so this year she plans to focus on expanding her company’s reach by hiring more matchmakers for the seven cities TDR currently operates in.

Photos of Three Day Rule's L.A. team

TDR plans to grow its team of matchmakers to better serve the cities where it has a presence.

Next year, she wants to add more cities to the TDR rolodex, and her strategic partnerships with companies like Match and OKCupid will help provide the client base needed to hit the ground running in new locations.

While Talia’s team consists of matchmakers with varied, impressive backgrounds, they all have one big thing in common: “At the end of the day, it comes down to soft skills.” What makes her matchmakers special is their ability to listen and dissect clients within the same conversation. Matchmakers have to be able to hear what the client says, but also ask the questions that will get at the heart of what the client really needs — to feel loved.

Advertiser Disclosure is a free online resource that offers valuable content and comparison services to users. To keep this resource 100% free, we receive compensation from many of the offers listed on the site. Along with key review factors, this compensation may impact how and where products appear across the site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). does not include the entire universe of available offers. Editorial opinions expressed on the site are strictly our own and are not provided, endorsed, or approved by advertisers.

Our Editorial Review Policy

Our site is committed to publishing independent, accurate content guided by strict editorial guidelines. Before articles and reviews are published on our site, they undergo a thorough review process performed by a team of independent editors and subject-matter experts to ensure the content’s accuracy, timeliness, and impartiality. Our editorial team is separate and independent of our site’s advertisers, and the opinions they express on our site are their own. To read more about our team members and their editorial backgrounds, please visit our site’s About page.