Should You Make Your Profile Universally Appealing

Online Dating

Should You Make Your Profile Universally Appealing?

Gina Stewart

Written by: Gina Stewart

Gina Stewart

Gina is the owner of Expert Online Dating. As an online dating consultant, she helps men and women maximize their online dating experiences to get more dates. You can visit her website,, for more information or to contact her.

See full bio »

Edited by: Lillian Castro

Lillian Castro

Lillian Guevara-Castro brings more than 30 years of journalism experience to ensure DatingAdvice articles have been edited for overall clarity, accuracy, and reader engagement. She has worked at The Atlanta Journal and Constitution, The Gwinnett Daily News, and The Gainesville Sun covering lifestyle topics.

Discuss This! Discuss This!
Advertiser Disclosure

I just read through a fascinating article that combed through tons of online dating data across, OkCupid, Grindr and Tinder.

It scoured all kinds of online daters and online dating behavior to define who the most successful online daters were, what they did and what you can take away from them in terms of helping your own online dating success.

For example, you should use words like “surfing” and “yoga” – the most popular daters in both sexes do.

The data also broke down gender differences that applied to more success (apparently retirement is a good word for older males to use but not women.)

Also, Sunday is a universally great day when most people go on online dating sites.

The amount of information they have is mind-numbing, and if you’re an online dating geek like I am, I can tell you I would have loved to have fallen down into that rabbit hole of data. Sigh. A girl can dream.

Curiously, there are some things the numbers and the stats can’t relay about online dating success. You can follow all of the suggested rules to make yourself the most popular bestest online dater ever. but it may not be your best bet.

Why would I do that?

What kind of online dating coach would coach that?

There are two philosophies I apply to how to approach online dating. The question to ask yourself is do you want to cast a wide net and appeal to as many daters as possible? Or do you want to cast a narrow net?

The idea is if you cast a wide net and do all of the things the most popular online daters do, you can get more views and dates. That may be awesome and exactly the thing for you.

I’ve always advocated getting yourself in front of as many people as possible and to use online dating as a catalyst to meet someone.

“There is a subset of daters who know

exactly what they are looking for.”

Who should cast a wide net?

  • Those who are new to dating and want to see what’s out there
  • Those who aren’t yet serious about dating
  • Those who want attention
  • Those who aren’t picky
  • Those who can’t be picky
  • Those who want quantity

Who should cast a narrow net?

You can still be a successful online dater and cast a narrow net.

There is a certain subset of daters who know exactly who they are and what they are looking for and their profile represents that.

Recently I was working with a dater who had done a lot of online dating and a significant amount of dating in general. She was at a ready age and had a clear list of deal-breakers and must-haves.

It’s not unusual for a dater to come to me with their list, but what was unusual was that while unique to her, her list wasn’t unreasonable.

Many lists I see are borderline ridiculous (“I can’t date a man who doesn’t wear a watch.”) Her must-haves spoke to her values and personality. The deal-breakers were nothing superficial.

We built her profile unapologetic to her truths and saturated in her sense of humor. The goal of this profile wasn’t to appeal to everyone.

She didn’t talk about how she could get dolled up and go on the town while she also loves to sit on the couch for a night in.

No, she wasn’t selling herself as a woman who was everything to everyone. Her profile was actually meant to turn off many men.

Why? Because the men who didn’t like what she had to say weren’t the type of person she would be interested in. She didn’t need a lot of emails in her inbox.

She didn’t get a lot of emails in her inbox.

She was still the most successful online dater, though.

In her first month online, one of the first emails she did receive was from a guy who thought her humor was hilarious, her mind brilliant and matched her values.

He liked that she didn’t sound like everyone else and that she embraced her faults and strengths. The chemistry was instant, and after a couple of months, they are in an exclusive relationship.

Have you thought about whether you’re trying to appeal to too many people in online dating?

Advertiser Disclosure is a free online resource that offers valuable content and comparison services to users. To keep this resource 100% free, we receive compensation from many of the offers listed on the site. Along with key review factors, this compensation may impact how and where products appear across the site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). does not include the entire universe of available offers. Editorial opinions expressed on the site are strictly our own and are not provided, endorsed, or approved by advertisers.

Our Editorial Review Policy

Our site is committed to publishing independent, accurate content guided by strict editorial guidelines. Before articles and reviews are published on our site, they undergo a thorough review process performed by a team of independent editors and subject-matter experts to ensure the content’s accuracy, timeliness, and impartiality. Our editorial team is separate and independent of our site’s advertisers, and the opinions they express on our site are their own. To read more about our team members and their editorial backgrounds, please visit our site’s About page.