Best Nyc Matchmakers 2023

Women's Dating

10 Best New York City Matchmakers of 2023

Sheena Holt

Written by: Sheena Holt

Sheena Holt

Sheena Holt comes to DatingAdvice with a BA in English and creative writing. Sheena's work has appeared in numerous literary and culture publications, including Lithium Magazine. Her work as an editor and writer has taught her a lot about the ins and outs of dating in the 21st century. As Managing Editor for DatingAdvice.com, she has interviewed hundreds of dating professionals and relationship experts. Sheena also enjoys writing long-form fiction in her spare time to keep her storytelling skills sharp.

See full bio »

Edited by: Lillian Castro

Lillian Castro

Lillian Guevara-Castro brings more than 30 years of journalism experience to ensure DatingAdvice articles have been edited for overall clarity, accuracy, and reader engagement. She has worked at The Atlanta Journal and Constitution, The Gwinnett Daily News, and The Gainesville Sun covering lifestyle topics.

Discuss This! Discuss This!

New York City is known for its unique brand of magic. Just think of how many iconic romantic comedies take place in New York – from the classic “When Harry Met Sally” to family favorite “Enchanted.” There’s something about New York City, beyond its iconic landscape and incredible diversity, that sets it apart as a romantic city.

According to U.S. Census Bureau 2020 data, New York City is home to over 8 million people, who are in a near-constant ebb and flow. One would assume that living in America’s largest city would make dating easier because New York’s dating pool is larger than dating pools in smaller cities. But more often than not, New York is one of the most difficult cities to date in. 

That’s where matchmakers come in. As movie-esque as the concept may sound, matchmakers can be highly effective resources who connect people every day. In a city as big as New York, daters sometimes need some help sorting through thousands of eligible singles. New York City’s top matchmakers connect compatible singles every day (and night!) in the city that never sleeps.

Modern Love Club | Agape | Luma Luxury | Maclynn | It’s Just Lunch | Sameera Sullivan | Janis Spindel | Cinqe | Kelleher International | MTN

Dubbed ‘The Matchmaker for Extraordinary People,’ Amy Van Doran is the founder and head matchmaker at the Modern Love Club. The Modern Love Club, which started as a performance art piece, has helped connect over 7,000 New Yorkers over the past decade. The matchmaking practice offers an in-person and hyper-curated approach to a client’s love life. The Modern Love Club is located in the heart of New York City’s East Village, a neighborhood known for its vibrant nightlife and distinctly New York feel. The physical space of the practice has the eclectic and colorful feel of an art gallery. While Amy Van Doran takes clients from all over the world, her focus is primarily in New York, San Francisco, and Los Angeles.

Amy is a certified matchmaker with the Matchmaking Institute and Matchmaker Alliance. In her 15 years as a matchmaker, she has personally interviewed over 15,000 singles. Amy considers matchmaking and listening to people talk about their relationship desires and goals her highest calling. 

Best for: Quirky couples

Agape, the Greek word for love, is a matchmaking firm that connects N.Y.C. singles every day. The matchmaking team at Agape knows how much New Yorkers value their time and privacy. They incorporate those values into their matchmaking approach, which is backed by their membership in the Matchmakers Alliance.

Maria Avgitidis leads the Agape team as the CEO and lead matchmaker. She has over a decade of matchmaking experience and has set up 5,000 first dates. She is supported by a five-person team with a diverse skill set that allows them to serve a wide array of clients.

Agape spends a lot of time getting to know their clients. Clients are highly vetted and interviewed by the Agape team, beginning from the first consultation. This consultation covers the dating history and core values of the prospective client. Once a client is onboarded, they receive hand-selected and intentional matches, plus an entirely planned first date.

Best for: Detailed Research

LUMA Luxury Matchmaking has a large team of expert matchmakers led by founder and president April Davis. LUMA Luxury’s team knows that finding “The One” can be a long and exhausting process. For some singles, it can feel impossible to find a partner no matter how hard they try. LUMA’s matchmaking service is personalized and confidential. LUMA listens to each of its client’s unique tastes and relationship expectations. Clients of LUMA can say goodbye to dating apps and instead receive a specialized list of potential partners hand-picked by the matchmaking team.

LUMA’s matchmaking efforts are focused on professionals, executives, and millionaires. This means New York City’s most successful can meet a match just as driven as they are through LUMA’s matchmakers. The team at LUMA knows that time is money and wants to help clients with busy schedules find love.

Best for: Executive Professionals

Maclynn

BEST
OF

Maclynn is an international team of matchmakers. They operate in large cities, including New York City, and their services are international. The agency was founded in 2011, and the team specializes in making personalized introductions and cultivating a client list of exemplary singles. Matchmaking services include receiving coaching, guidance, and regular feedback to achieve the best fit.

The team at Maclynn understands how difficult it is to date in New York City, especially for busy professionals who don’t have the time for bad first dates. Maclynn wants to match people who are highly compatible, have shared goals and interests, and are done playing dating games.

Maclynn offers two kinds of matchmaking services. The private membership gives clients an assigned matchmaker who will provide guaranteed introductions, searches for compatible matches, and access to over 17,000 vetted members. The open membership is strictly invite-only and gives members the opportunity to be matched with a private member.

Best for: International Matchmaking

Covering over 200 cities and sparking the magic for over 2 million first dates, the team at It’s Just Lunch knows how to make a connection. It’s Just Lunch is a private premium dating service that helps busy professionals find their match. It’s Just Lunch clients receive more than just matchmaking; they are guaranteed dates as part of the matchmaking service.

It’s Just Lunch clients can say goodbye to dating apps. The firm works to cultivate a private experience and takes confidentiality seriously. The team will even assist clients in finding a restaurant or other date location, and making reservations. All prospective matches are handpicked with care.

The firm’s signature process includes a session where the client can share with their matchmaker their story, values, and goals. After this, the matchmaker will begin to make their expert selections, and – voila! — a first date with a hand-selected match.

Best for: Proven Results

Sameera Sullivan founded her first matchmaking service in 2012 with the goal of creating an elite and highly effective matchmaking firm. She combined her background in psychology and postsecondary adult education with experience in executive recruiting to form a powerhouse of a matchmaking firm. Sameera offers services geared toward women and men of all backgrounds and orientations.

Sameera works closely with LGBTQ+ relationship coaches and matchmaking experts to help gay men find their perfect match. Sameera has a unique skill set for helping women attract quality partners. She focuses much of her matchmaking talents on helping successful and secure women meet partners who match their values and lifestyle.

Sameera offers several different packages clients can choose from. All packages are complete with a boutique matchmaking experience. This includes direct private access to Sameera, vetted matches, and quick match turnaround.

Best for: One-on-One Matchmaking

Janis Spindel Matchmaking’s slogan — Men are our clients and romance is our business — pretty much says it all. Janis Spindel Matchmaking is focused on helping ambitious and successful men make quality connections. Led by mother-daughter duo Carly and Janis Spindel, the matchmakers provide luxury matchmaking services to their clients.

Janis Spindel Matchmaking knows money can’t buy love, but it can help in finding connections. The firm’s expert team does in-depth research on clients and prospective matches, and the matchmakers want the first dates they set up to eventually become serious, long-term relationships. The Janis Spindel Matchmaking firm has made over 5,000 matches that have resulted in marriage since it was founded in 1993.

With a matchmaking experience designed to take all the pressure off their clientele, Janis and Carly interview hundreds of women every year to add to their “Our Love Sphere,” which is made up of the most eligible single women in New York City, the tri-state area, and beyond.

Best for: Men’s Luxury Matchmaking

Cinqe Matchmaking’s luxury team of certified matchmakers help successful men find beautiful women for lasting relationships. Founded by lead matchmaker Erica Arrechea in 2011, Cinqe has matchmakers who have the unique ability to understand what each client is looking for. Erica and her team have helped countless singles fall in love.

Cinqe’s matchmaking services are focused on extremely successful and/or high-profile men who require a trusted service. The firm specializes in ‘picky’ clients, introverted clients, and clients tired of playing the online dating game. Cinqe helps men find a match among its network of 60,000 people and growing.

Cinqe has a large practice in New York City, but its reach is global. The company offers its services from Los Angeles to Dubai, which means highly successful men can find their match – even if she lives on the other side of the world. This group of elite matchmakers works day in and day out to find their clients the woman of their dreams.

Best for: Perfectly Picky Clients

The matchmaking team at Kelleher International knows how hard it is to make a true love connection in New York City. Kelleher International helps clients who are single, successful, and looking for a long-term romantic relationship. Led by the mother-daughter team of Jill Kelleher and her daughter Amber Kelleher-Andrews, the matchmaking firm is ranked as the #1 Global Matchmaking Service.

Kelleher International’s clients are often singles who are successful and ambitious. Previous clients have included celebrities, athletes, entrepreneurs, and CEOs. Kelleher International is based in New York City but is a global matchmaking firm. Their global network is exclusive and includes only the most eligible singles.

Prospective clients will complete an online form to see whether they are eligible for membership. If they are approved, they can then discuss the membership options with the team. From there, a personalized team of matchmaking experts will begin making hand-selected matches.

Best for: Upscale Global Matchmaking

Long Island’s only executive-level certified matchmaker Maureen Tara Nelson is a bit of a celebrity around Long Island. She’s the owner of MTN Matchmaking, a dedicated firm made up of matchmaking experts. MTN is best known for making connections on Long Island and in other areas just outside the city.

Maureen herself has over 22 years of experience in matchmaking and has set up over 1,000 clients. Prospective clients will have an introductory profile analysis, which determines whether they will be a good fit for MTN’s services. The firm prides itself on hand-selected matches that are carefully chosen after a compatibility analysis.

MTN offers a variety of services in a few different price ranges. This means their client pool is diverse and many different kinds of people find success. The programs range from the low-cost trial program to the elite program. MTN Matchmaking is so committed to helping people find love that their celebrity matchmaking program is a fraction of the cost of competitors.

Best for: Long Island Singles

Matchmakers are for any single looking for a specialized and unique connection, not just those who haven’t had any luck dating on their own. Each of these matchmakers or matchmaking groups specializes in something different, meaning there’s a good match for anyone no matter what they’re looking for.

These matchmakers offer a diverse range of services that can be helpful to many kinds of singles living in New York City. As online dating grows in popularity and more people connect for romance on the internet, singles can become overwhelmed or exhausted.

Matchmaking takes the extraneous work out of dating and matches singles ready for long-term relationships with each other. Singles who choose to work with any of these matchmakers no longer have to worry about making sure their date agrees with their fundamental values and lifestyle choices. Instead, they can focus on cultivating a real connection.