“Compatible Partners” — Review of the Service (And 5 Other Gay Sites)

Gay Dating

“Compatible Partners” — Review of the Service (And 5 Other Gay Sites)

Amber Brooks Amber Brooks

Around 2008, eHarmony was getting some flack because the site wasn’t perceived as gay- and lesbian-friendly, as singles could only choose between “man seeking woman” or “woman seeking man.” To better cater to this audience, eHarmony launched Compatible Partners in 2009 — a place where gay men and lesbian women could go without having to weed through thousands or millions of profiles of straight singles.

We’ll walk you through our feelings about Compatible Partners (the signup, the matching, the features, the success rate, etc.) and offer up some other gay and lesbian dating sites to consider so you’ve got all the facts before making your final decision.

Compatible Partners Review | 5 Other Gay Sites

Compatible Partners: Accurate Matching But Limited Free Features (4.3/5.0 Rating)

Unlike their sister site, Compatible Partners is open to gay men or lesbian women of all ages, races, religions, cultures, and backgrounds who are looking for a serious relationship, not a hookup. As we mentioned earlier, the service was created in 2009 to address the specific needs of homosexual singles, particularly those who are religious.

Photo of the Compatible Partners app

On Compatible Partners, it’s 100% free to register, create a profile, and receive matches.

Compatible Partners has a similar in-depth questionnaire as eHarmony (which includes about 150 questions and takes about an hour to complete if you’re really detailed) and uses the same patented Compatibility Matching System to help you find your ideal partner. However, unlike in the past, new members are no longer required to answer every question on the questionnaire. So the signup process should take no more than 10 minutes if you just want to get to it.

Some pieces of information Compatible Partners does require is your first name, gender, the gender you’re looking for, location, email, password, and how you heard about the site. Registration is 100% free as are these features:

  • Take the exclusive questionnaire
  • Receive your own personality profile
  • Get matches who meet your criteria sent to your inbox
  • Send virtual winks

If you want access to more features, which you’ll need if you want to actually have a conversation with your matches, you’ll have to upgrade. The pricing for the Basic Plan is $19.95 a month for 12 months, $29.90 a month for six months, $29.95 a month for three months, and $59.95 for one month. The pricing for the TotalConnect Plan is $23.95 a month for 12 months, $33.95 a month for six months, or $44.95 a month for three months. The last option is the Premier Plan, which costs $41.95 a month for 12 months. As you can probably see, the latter is the way to go because you’ll get the most bang for your buck.

Premium features include viewing more photos, getting a deeper look into your personality profile, and using Guided Communication and SecureCall to message and talk with matches. Note: All of these subscriptions require you to pay the total amount upfront or in three increments, so make sure you check the fine print before clicking that upgrade button.

Besides the technical aspects of Compatible Partners, you’ll also want to know what users themselves think about the site. One success story we were particularly touched by is that of Don and Keleko. After ending a relationship of 22 years, Don was newly single and doubtful about his chances of finding love again. Keleko, whose partner passed away from a heart attack after 20 years together, was in a similar situation.

Photo of Don and Keleko, a Compatible Partners success story

Don and Keleko weren’t sure about online dating when they signed up for Compatible Partners, but they found each other within a few months and quickly fell in love.

They both warily joined Compatible Partners and were matched a few months later. Long messages turned into long email exchanges, and long email exchanges turned into long phone calls. Soon Don was traveling to Maui to meet Keleko in person. The chemistry they felt online intensified offline, and before they knew it, Don was packing up his stuff, moving in with Keleko, and they were getting married in a traditional Hawaiian ceremony. The rest is history thanks to Compatible Partners.

Don credits his success to the site’s highly accurate matching and advanced chatting features, which gave him and Keleko various ways to share their interests, passions, beliefs, and goals with one another.

“The beauty of Compatible Partners is by the time we met, we already knew each other very well,” Don told Compatible Partners. “As I said to Keleko in my wedding vows, ‘I have waited for you for 60 years. I can’t believe God has blessed us with this union. It was every bit worth the wait.’

You can read more stories like this on Compatible Partners Success Stories page.

5 Other Gay Dating Sites to Try

The main thing people seem to dislike about Compatible Partners is that they can’t browse through profiles or start conversations with members on their own — most of the control is in the site’s hands. If you’re the type of person who wants to be in the driver’s seat, especially since it’s your dating life, you’ll definitely be interested in these alternative gay dating sites.

Whether you’re a gay black single looking for someone special within your own race, place a heavy emphasis on a person’s level of education, have a preferred age range, care about the app experience, or want it all rolled into one — you’ll find the right site for you in the list below. Plus, they all offer free trials or memberships, so you can test the waters first — no need to jump all the way in if you’re unsure.


Relationships: Friends, Dates, and Relationships

Match System: Browse by zip, age, appearance, more

Our Experts Say: “Match.com has a massive and extremely active gay user base, as over 1 million gay, bisexual, and curious men use the site to find dates and partners...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

Match is the most well-known and well-established name in the online dating industry, and it’s a great choice for gay singles. The site has 30 million members and sees 13.5 million visitors every month, so finding that diamond in the rough should take no time at all.


Relationships: Fun Dates, Serious Relationships

Match System: Search and get match recommendations

Our Experts Say: “Gay, bisexual, and curious single men love Zoosk because it's quick, easy, and really successful...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

We’re all swamped with work, family, and other life obligations, which is why Zoosk is our go-to for gay daters who are on the run all the time. Download the app via iTunes or Google Play, and you can find compatible matches whether you’re in line at Starbucks, are on your commute to work, or are anywhere else in the world.


Relationships: Dates and Relationships

Match System: Search by profiles by zip and more

Our Experts Say: “OurTime is a fantastic option for gay, bisexual, and curious single men age 50 and up, as the site's user base is very active...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

OurTime may be exclusively for mature singles, but other than that, its user base is vast. You’ll have the opportunity to meet people from numerous backgrounds and of varying sexual orientations. Plus, OurTime has one of the easiest interfaces, so if you’re not very confident in your tech skills, you don’t have to worry about it.


Relationships: Serious Relationships

Match System: Search, Receive Partner Suggestions

Our Experts Say: “EliteSingles is a leading dating site just for busy, single professionals. More than 80% of members have earned a college degree, and most are looking for a serious commitment...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

Age, gender, location — these are all common dating preferences, but what about education? If that’s on your list, look no further than EliteSingles. About 80% of its members have a bachelor’s, master’s, or doctorate degree, so you know the quality of people you’ll be surrounded by is high. Just choose your match’s ideal education and sexual orientation, and you should be good to go.


Relationships: Deep Relationships or Just Casual Dates

Match System: Search by location, age, more

Our Experts Say: “BlackPeopleMeet is a go-to dating site for gay, bisexual, and curios black and biracial men, and it has a free membership option...” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

BlackPeopleMeet is a favorite among black or biracial gay singles because the site knows how to cater to this audience. Some of BlackPeopleMeet’s most helpful features include live chat, conversational icebreakers, and hand-picked matches based on your individual criteria.

Consider Compatible Partners While Keeping Your Options Open

Because eHarmony is such a trusted brand in the dating industry, that makes Compatible Partners a reliable choice as well. What gay singles used to on eHarmony is no longer an issue — on Compatible Partners, they can rest assured that they’re around their desired audience.

The scientific matching system (which was created by clinical psychologist, Christian theologian, and seminary professor Dr. Neil Clark Warren) is unlike any other you’ll find on the web. And a new perk is you can spend as much or as little time on it as you want.

While the free features do leave something to be desired (after all, communicating is a pretty important part of online dating), it’s a good way to get a feel for the service to see if you really want to go this route. But remember to take some time to shop around. Gay dating sites abound, and Compatible Partners, as well as the services we’ve suggested, is just one of them.