Christian Mingle Vs Eharmony

Online Dating

Christian Mingle vs eharmony (Feb. 2024)

Anggi Pradhini

Written by: Anggi Pradhini

Anggi Pradhini

Anggi Pradhini is a professional copywriter who creates unique, engaging, and up-to-date content for DatingAdvice.com. As a former stockbroker turned professional writer, she loves to challenge herself to broaden her horizons and improve her skills, one article at a time. After learning from the breakups of three long-term relationships, she dedicated her life to providing informative and relatable content about relationships and dating for those who need it.

Edited by: Lillian Castro

Lillian Castro

Lillian Guevara-Castro brings more than 30 years of journalism experience to ensure DatingAdvice articles have been edited for overall clarity, accuracy, and reader engagement. She has worked at The Atlanta Journal and Constitution, The Gwinnett Daily News, and The Gainesville Sun covering lifestyle topics.

Discuss This! Discuss This!
Advertiser Disclosure

eharmony and Christian Mingle both launched in the 2000s and don’t show any sign of fading in their popularity any time soon. With a legacy spanning over two decades, these platforms have solidified a global reputation as dating websites that help singles find their long-term partner

But Christian Mingle and eharmony have different ways of finding matches for their members. The eharmony dating service is famous for using a psychological approach to help users find a potential partner. Meanwhile, Christian Mingle caters to the Christian community and provides religious search filters and spiritual icebreakers for its membership.

Our experts have assessed Christian Mingle and eharmony based on their membership demographic, matchmaking tools, pricing, and success rates, so online daters can make  thoughtful decisions that suit their needs. Keep reading to learn the pros and cons and our recommendations on choosing the best tool for you.

User Base | Features | Cost Comparison | Success Rate

Who Does It Help? Membership Base Demographics

Christian Mingle and eharmony have similar audiences. Both dating platforms strive to attract singles who are looking for serious relationships. The difference is Christian Mingle focuses more on faith-based relationships, while eharmony uses a lengthy compatibility quiz to find the best match for its users.

eharmony Helps Singles Adults Who Are Ready for Commitment

When Dr. Neil Clark Warren launched eharmony in early 2000, he wanted to build a dating website to help values-driven singles find serious relationships that lead to marriage. Fast forward to today, eharmony boasts pairing over 2 million happy couples in the U.S. alone.

★★★★★
eharmony 4.8/5.0

Our expert ratings are based on factors such as popularity, usability, value, and success rate of each site.

4.8/5.0

Relationships: Casual Dates, Deep Relationships

Match System: Personality test suggests matches

Our Experts Say: “Accounting for 2% of U.S. marriages, eharmony’s compatibility-based system and commitment-minded user base are ideal for those seeking a serious relationship…” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

Moreover, Bloomberg estimated that couples who meet on eharmony have a divorce rate of 3.86%, far lower than the national U.S. divorce rate. This means that a couple who meets on eharmony finds a long-term partner who is the right partner. Needless to say, eharmony’s psychological test digs deep to reveal matches that align with a single’s personality and interests, and makes eharmony a champion of love in the online dating world.

Christian Mingle Connects Christian Singles Worldwide

Christian Mingle is by far the most popular Christian dating site on the market. Spark Network designed the platform to help God-centric singles find their soulmates. The dating platform’s matching tools can help Christian singles find their first date, which can hopefully lead to a serious relationship. The fact that Christian Mingle has 2.4 million visitors each month shows that people enjoy using this dating site.

★★★★★
ChristianMingle 4.5/5.0

Our expert ratings are based on factors such as popularity, usability, value, and success rate of each site.

4.5/5.0

Relationships: Dates and Serious Relationships

Match System: Search by gender, age, education, more

Our Experts Say: “ChristianMingle is among the largest dating sites in the industry that only caters to single Christian men and women, and the site has some of the best search filters and safety features…” Full Review »

Browse Free: View Photos Now

For over two decades, Christian Mingle has ignited countless relationships and marriages between Christian couples. According to a survey of American Christians, about 29% of all Christian marriages that originated online started on this dating site. This fact solidifies Christian Mingle’s position as the premier dating site for Christians to find a date. No surprise that 80% of Christian Mingle members would recommend it to a friend.

How Does It Work? Compatibility Matchmaking & Filters

Every online dating site has one purpose: finding a great match for its users. Positive testimonials show that people loved their online dating experience and feel it was a success. And that’s better for business. 

Exactly how an online dating site algorithm finds matches is a trade secret that sets each platform apart from its competitors. Now, let’s learn how Christian Mingle and eharmony filter and match their members.

eharmony Makes Smart Matches Based on a Personality Test

eharmony has been famous for using its trademark personality assessment that includes dozens of questions about the person’s likes, dislikes, hobbies, dealbreakers, and goals. The eharmony team encourages all members to complete the personality test if they want to get the best result. Once users submit their responses, eharmony’s Compatibility Matching System will use that information to identify compatible matches.

Screenshot of eharmony
eharmony connects members with profiles that have high compatibility ratings.

The eharmony matchmaking system puts quality first. Every dating profile recommended to you by eharmony has been vetted by the algorithm and has a high compatibility score according to your personality test. Put simply, you’re more likely to hit it off with profiles suggested to you through eharmony’s algorithm. 

In addition to the smart matching, you can also filter the match recommendation by age, city, and other characteristics to further narrow your dating pool.

Christian Mingle Has Unique Search Filters Based on Christian Values

It’s well-known that Christian Mingle serves the Christian community. The app’s design is all about finding users potential partners who align with their faith. The algorithm provides a curated list of daily match profiles based on the user’s date preferences and Christian values. Users can set discovery preferences for their perfect match’s gender, age, religion, location, and relationship type.

Christian Mingle homepage

A free membership on Christian Mingle allows a user to browse the database by filtering according to new members, who’s online, proximity, and match percentage. When the Christian Mingle user discovers an interesting dating profile, the next step is to send a virtual wink to show interest.

A user with a free membership on Christian Mingle cannot initiate a conversation. Instead, they must wait for a premium member to message first. Free members can respond to every message in their inbox without paying a cent. 

What’s It Cost? Price Comparison of Premium Memberships

Online dating has become a major part of modern love life. Approximately 30% of Americans surveyed by Pew Research Center said they have used an app to find love. Experts estimate that around 20% of current committed relationships started with dating sites. 

Moreover, the barrier to trying online dating is so low that any single person can give it a try. Most mainstream dating services offer a free membership, and Christian Mingle and eharmony are no exception. But if you want to elevate your success rate in finding your match, you may want to consider upgrading to paid membership. We’ll break down the pricing you can expect.

Join eharmony Free! Optional Paid Plan Starts at $65

All eharmony users begin with a free membership that allows them to view local profiles and express interest in a potential match. If you want to send private messages, however, you will need to upgrade to premium membership starting at $65 for one month.

Don’t be surprised by the price – eharmony has been known to set high prices for its paid membership plans. This price tag acts as a filter to make sure eharmony users are financially stable and ready to start serious relationships.

But due to today’s economic struggle, eharmony is welcoming back post-COVID daters by reducing the price by up to 40%. Here are the most recent prices you can expect for eharmony premium membership:

  • $21.54/mo for 24 months — one-time payment of $516.96
  • $27.54/mo for 12 months — one-time payment of $330.48
  • $39.54/mo for 6 months — one-time payment of $237.24

When you decide to become a premium eharmony member, you don’t only have to pay a high price, you also have to commit to a minimum of six months as a paid member on the dating site. This will discourage many casual daters from signing up, enabling eharmony to compile lists of singles who are willing to invest their money and time in finding serious partners for their life.

Christian Mingle Has Some Free Chatting. Extra Features Cost $44.99

Just like eharmony, a single person can use Christian Mingle for free. You can register for a free account and browse through potential matches for an unlimited time. But only premium members of Christian Mingle are allowed to send and read messages, access photos, see who’s liked their profiles, and join as many chat rooms as they like. Simply put, you can window-shop for free on Christian Mingle, but you need to pay to play. 

Compared to eharmony, Christian Mingle has a more affordable price tag of $44.99 for one month. Here’s the price breakdown for Christian Mingle premium membership:

  • $24.99/mo for 6 months
  • $34.99/mo for 3 months
  • $44.99/mo for one month

Clearly, you can save more money over time if you commit to the longer Christian Mingle subscription plan. If you’re serious about finding the right Christian person as a partner, it’s well worth upgrading your membership and investing in your future happiness. 

Does It Get Results? Success Stories & User Reviews

The fact that Christian Mingle and eharmony have existed for 20 years is pretty good proof on its own that both of them do good work. But still, it’s interesting to check the success stories and reviews that show how each of these premium dating sites serves modern members.

eharmony Has Connected 2 Million Couples — And Counting!

eharmony’s matchmaking system shows its effectiveness by helping almost three-quarters of men and women meet their spouses within a year of joining the site or app. The online matching system creates about 15 million matches every day.

Now, let’s talk about the real people who get results from eharmony. Meet Kristen and Dominick, a happy couple from Louisburg, Kansas. Kristen joined eharmony in 2020 hoping to meet people during the lockdown, and she quickly found Dominick as one of her matches. Dominick signed up on a whim, and Kristen’s dating profile was on the first page of his potential matches.

“Before they knew it, 9 hours had elapsed. It was safe to say they would be meeting again soon.” — eharmony success story

After a couple of weeks of chatting by text and video calls — in proper Covid fashion — they were both eager to meet in person. In the summer of 2020, they had their first date, which lasted nine hours, but to them it went by in a flash. Everything went so well that Dominick got down on one knee to propose to Kristen on May 1, 2021.

Christian Mingle Is Most Successful at Inspiring Christian Marriages

Let’s dig deeper to see what real people say about Christian Mingle. Head over to Google Play, and you’ll find that this online dating app has numerous five-star ratings. A Christian Mingle user named Sean Hackney even said, “Between school, the Marine Corps, and my son… I didn’t know how I would ever meet a good woman. Christian Mingle is amazing, and I’m really happy with the app and website.”

Photo of Alicia and Luck on their wedding day
Alicia and Luke met on Christian Mingle and got engaged a few months later.

One touching love story comes from Alicia and Luke, who met on Christian Mingle and went on their first date at a local Mexican restaurant for lunch. It was a little bit awkward in the beginning, but things went so well afterward that they knew the relationship was something special. The couple ended up getting engaged after dating for three months. They’re now happily married.

Alicia and Luke’s advice for those who want to find love on Christian Mingle is simple: “Be careful. Be open and honest. Let God lead.”

Alicia and Luke’s love story is not an anomaly on Christian Mingle. If you’re a faith-driven single, Christian Mingle might be the dating app for you!

Verdict: Both Are Great, But Our Experts Rank eharmony Higher

While our dating experts have good things to say about Christian Mingle and eharmony, if we had to choose only one, the winner would be eharmony. Our research shows that eharmony reaches wider audiences, and its patented matchmaking questionnaire makes the dating platform stand out. The only downside of eharmony is that the premium membership is a bit pricey. But eharmony’s impressive success rate shows it is worth the investment.

eharmony logo
eharmony is a trusted dating platform with over two decades of success stories.

The only matchup where Christian Mingle beats eharmony is if you’re looking for a romantic partner who shares the same religious passion. In this specific need, Christian Mingle serves its members best because it caters to Christian individuals, so religion isn’t a tricky subject to bring up with your date.

Now it’s up to you to decide which way to go. If you’re looking for true love and a deep matchmaking experience (no swiping!), eharmony is a good choice with time-tested success. If spirituality and faith are a key part of your life, you may want to go with Christian Mingle.

And remember, you can always keep your options open with a free membership on both dating sites. That way, you can make an informed choice for your dating life. Best of luck!

Advertiser Disclosure

DatingAdvice.com is a free online resource that offers valuable content and comparison services to users. To keep this resource 100% free, we receive compensation from many of the offers listed on the site. Along with key review factors, this compensation may impact how and where products appear across the site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). DatingAdvice.com does not include the entire universe of available offers. Editorial opinions expressed on the site are strictly our own and are not provided, endorsed, or approved by advertisers.

Our Editorial Review Policy

Our site is committed to publishing independent, accurate content guided by strict editorial guidelines. Before articles and reviews are published on our site, they undergo a thorough review process performed by a team of independent editors and subject-matter experts to ensure the content’s accuracy, timeliness, and impartiality. Our editorial team is separate and independent of our site’s advertisers, and the opinions they express on our site are their own. To read more about our team members and their editorial backgrounds, please visit our site’s About page.